Starmer accused of acting like monarch in vote row


Labour’s former shadow chancellor has suggested leader Sir Keir Starmer was acting like a monarch in a rift over the party’s policy on electoral reform.

John McDonnell is backing a proposed change to Labour’s position on the UK’s voting system.

At Labour’s conference, he said policy decisions were taken democratically and “no-one is above that”.

But Sir Keir has said electoral reform was not a priority under his leadership.

The Labour leader is facing increasing pressure to drop the party’s historical support for the first-past-the-post voting system used for general elections in the UK.

MPs from all wings of the party have been urging him to instead embrace some level of proportional representation.

Proportional representation, or PR, is the idea that the seats in Parliament should reflect the number of votes cast.

Democracies around the world use various polling methods that ensure that voters feel their vote counts – in some cases it is simply that they indicate a second-choice candidate that they can show their backing for once their preferred choice is out of the running. This is not strictly proportional representation but is often put forward by supporters of PR as a fairer method of representing voters’ wishes.

  • Why don’t we elect MPs by proportional representation?
  • Labour looks more united as conference starts
  • Talks with minister a good start, says RMT’s Lynch

The Labour for a New Democracy campaign wants the leadership to back the introduction of PR its next election manifesto.

Labour members are set to debate support for this at Labour’s conference in Liverpool, where the proposal will be voted on this week.

But Labour sources have suggested that PR will not be put in the manifesto, even if members vote for it at conference.

In an interview with the Observer newspaper this week, Sir Keir suggested he would not put a pledge for electoral reform in Labour’s manifesto.

Appearing at a pro-PR rally organised by Labour for a New Democracy, Mr McDonnell said he had seen Sir Keir’s comments.

“I think we just have to remind, as gently as we can, that all our decisions are taken democratically,” Mr McDonnell said.

“I think Keir’s been mixing with the royalty too much for the last few days. He’s not a feudal monarchy.

“He’s an elected leader of the party, accountable to the party and accountable to all of us.

“We have a democratic structure by which we determine those decisions. I hope that we’ll be able to reflect that in a constructive dialogue.”

He said he was confident PR would be in the party’s manifesto by the next annual conference.

Mr McDonnell was one of the architects of Labour’s 2017 and 2019 election manifestos under the previous leader, left-wing MP Jeremy Corbyn.

The former shadow chancellor told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme that the 2019 election, which resulted in an 80-seat majority for the Conservative Party, showed that the current first-past-the-post system was “unfair”.

“I still think Labour will get an overall majority in the next election, but we’ve got to say to people we need a fair voting system because we need a government that actually does represent the people,” he added.

About the author

Olivia Wilson
By Olivia Wilson


Get in touch

Content and images available on this website is supplied by contributors. As such we do not hold or accept liability for the content, views or references used. For any complaints please contact Use of this website signifies your agreement to our terms of use. We do our best to ensure that all information on the Website is accurate. If you find any inaccurate information on the Website please us know by sending an email to and we will correct it, where we agree, as soon as practicable. We do not accept liability for any user-generated or user submitted content – if there are any copyright violations please notify us at – any media used will be removed providing proof of content ownership can be provided. For any DMCA requests under the digital millennium copyright act
Please contact: with the subject DMCA Request.